The Horse Forum (http://www.horseforum.com/forumindex.php)
- Horse Training (/horse-training/)
- - Haute Ecole, crank nosebands and "natural horsemanship"? (http://www.horseforum.com/horse-training/haute-ecole-crank-nosebands-natural-horsemanship-72295/)
Haute Ecole, crank nosebands and "natural horsemanship"?
Please note, I put quotations on "natural horsemanship" as my personal jury is still out on the naturality of the horsemanship school talked about..
Ok so today I was looking on YouTube watching Haute Ecole videos, you know, white stallions rearing and leaping and dancing, when I found this video on bits. If you type "Nevzorov-haute-ecole school" into the search you probably can find it. It is saying that the Nevzorov school teaches Haute Ecole without bits or bridles, and that bits are bad, evil things, etc. Notice the rider's expressions and arms in the bit pictures, and take note of horse's ears in the Haute Ecole. I'm sure I saw some ears back at one point... check out the website and let me know what you think. Are they genuine? Can you teach this stuff without bridles? Are bits really that bad?
I saw some ears back, but I didn't really catch any that were back in a way that was aggressive or threatening to the trainer(s). With a rider, it appears that the horse is listening for cues ("flicking" its ears back in forth, such as the sorrel in the beginning doing a pivot). Same with the black horse still picture that was rearing; it doesn't seem to be doing so out of malice or threats.
In my [brief] experience, I know that back ears don't always mean you're about to be bit/kicked/challenged. At the stable I work at we have a yearling (lovingly named Thunder Wolf) who, once you approach him, will pin his ears and drop his head to "glare" at you; however, he will not bite (save for to maybe nibble on your coat sleeve or nip your boots), kick, or pull back at your touches.
I also noticed the horse bucking in the beginning of the video at the trainer's request: perhaps the ears being back are associated with the action normally depicted as aggressive among other horses? Simple habit?
I'm not against bits at all. I ride Creampuff, my mare, with a French link bit and it takes a light touch to the reign and a vocal command (mostly "ho!" for stop) to get her to carry out my request. She receives this bit well! Otherwise, of the other horses, we commonly use the Western or Snaffle bits. Some of them would reject this, so you have to have a louder hand than you would on Creampuff.
I suppose it would depend on the horse and rider. I know a lot of inexperienced riders use loud hands and no leg pressure, while more "seasoned" riders use more of their legs and a soft hand while maintaining an assertive disposition. Obviously I have no reason to not use a bit, even though I have seen some people yank on a poor horse's face; but if someone were to cause my horse's mouth to bleed with it, my perspective could very well change. (Many horses would then reject a bridle/bit due to fear of being injured again, as I've experienced before when a horse came in from the pasture with a cut lip.)
Regardless, I do rather like their method. The horses seem happier to work, whereas some livery horses I have seen will pin their ears and sometimes even buck when asked to work. The trainers' arms seem to be the horse's cue to perform (such as the one with the "bouncing" hand and the horse crow hopping alongside him).
Simply, yes. It is possible to teach them all this without the bit and bridle. Instead they use a string around the horses neck called a cordeo (if anything at all ). Same function as the bridle but much less harsh. It takes a lot of time and training to get them used to it though but they seem much happier and relaxed. I some times play with my girl using one and she is much more responsive and happy to do what i am asking her with it. And yes they think bits and all that are evil if you were to keep looking into that you would find that they dont allow anyone to ride thier horse anymore. As that is not what horses are made to do.
Posted via Mobile Device
Bits are only as evil as the hands using them.
Horses with their ears tipped back are frequently concentrating or "listening" to the rider. It's only when they're flattened against the horse's neck that it's a true sign of aggression or displeasure.
|All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:13 AM.|
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2016 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.