I have been looking into different saddle pads and im really liking the ones with open cell foam on the bottom or fleece (wool and felt make my mare itchy and cause her to get bumps!! ) my mare has big shoulders and not very promanent withers and is also built SLIGHTLY down hill, I am looking for a pad that will help lift my saddle off her shoulders possibly? These are three of the pads I've been looking at, let me know what you think and if you have expierience with any of them or any other pad that might help please!!
You are shopping for the wrong item. You need either a crupper or mule breeching, also known as spider breeching. Either one will hold the saddle from crawling forward. Trying to compensate with a pad will cause the saddle to float up onto the shoulder blades.
Are you placing the saddle on her back or on the shoulder blades? From your description the saddle is on the shoulder blades which is incorrect. The bars, not the skirts, need to be about two fingers behind the shoulder blades.