The older saddle seems to have bars that aren't quite angled like Semi-QH but it's tricky to draw a direct comparison because one is new and fluffy underneath where as the wool on the older saddle is really worn down. Tried that one on too, and its a bit wide without a built up pad, but with the built up to me it looked okay? Ran my hand under and it felt like an even pressure and to me that saddle always "sits" better than other.
What's your general opinion, if any?
Synthetic by itself
Synthetic with built up pad
Synthetic side on
Older saddle by itself - this picture kind of makes it look like it's just touching behind the rosette, but it's not really, it's just how it looks the next pic with the pad probably shows the angle better
Older saddle with built up
Older saddle side