If only you could try one for a bit. It's one of those things, either you love 'em or you hate 'em. I didn't like the feel of them, but I am kind of a fat lady and I appreciate the saddle tree creating a "twist" in the middle , between my legs, which helps me keep my legs hanging down correctly. Riding bareback or in a treeless, my knees tend to rotate out quite a bit.
But that is just me.
There's another member on here, Gidget, who I know just bought a Barefoot Cheyenne saddle. Maybe you should "friend" her and ask her opinion.