Haha, thanks! You're not making this easy but at least I know none of them are completely hideous :). My ulterior motive in asking is that I have spent 6 months researching western saddles for trail riding and skijoring and have finally narrowed it down to 2, both of which I think would be an excellent fit for my horse and for me, but I'm finding it impossible to narrow it down any further. I called both companies and neither carry saddles in tack shops anywhere near me so I can't try them out and am forced to buy online and just hope I make the right choice (or face return shipping and restocking fees).
So as 4Horses posted, color is the least concern when buying a saddle, and she's absolutely right, but I'm out of deciding factors to help me make my decision, because both saddles seem to fit the bill! The top saddle is a barrel racing saddle and only comes in that light tan which I think is gorgeous. The other saddle is a trail saddle and comes in brown but I can have it made in black. My horse is a black old-style Morgan. Anyway, I just wanted to see if anyone said "Eewwwwww!" to any of them but it seems to be split pretty evenly among you (and in my mind!)