I bought a pad from a woman that makes them herself and OMG I LOVE it!
It has a wool felt underside, which is what drew me to it. My gelding doesn't love sheepskin, makes him itchy and I don't like neoprene much. She makes it with a "sticky" seat...my goodness does it feel secure. She has all kinds of color options and add ons you can get too.
It was a little more expensive then I ever thought I'd spend on a pad but it had EVERYTHING I wanted. The sticky seat, tons of d-rings, no grab handle (I feel those give false security) and of course no stirrups.
You can find her on facebook "Trailmaster Bareback Pads and Accessories" or
www.trailmasterbp.com
I don't think I'd ever buy a bareback pad from anyone else now, I love this one.