The Horse Forum banner
Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 20 of 27 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
2,847 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Anyone have any expierence with Dakota barrel saddles? I went saddle shopping today and found a nice 16 in barrel saddle. All leather. Suuuuuper comfy. Brand spankin new for $600 plus a trade in on my old ancient saddle. They retail $1000 + the guy said.

This isn't the exact one but same thing.
http://www.horsesaddleshop.com/dakota-barrel-racer.html
Posted via Mobile Device
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rawhide

· Registered
Joined
·
112 Posts
Dak-353 base price is $690.99
Dak-345 base price is $726.99
Dak-342 base price is $666.99
Dak-325C base price is $714.99
Dak-310 base price is $738.99
Dak-314 base price is $696.99
Dak-307 base price is $708.99
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,847 Posts
Discussion Starter · #5 ·
I actually just got a Dakota barrel racer for 650 + trade in on my old 50 yr old saddle. My parents gift to me for Christmas :)
Posted via Mobile Device
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,148 Posts
From what I understand, they are a pretty decent saddle. They are no Circle Y or Martin type of saddle, but they are not junk either. I guess you would call them middle of the line. Either way, a great investment if you are not looking for junk or a super expensive saddle.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,847 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
Well come to find out what I thought was my old, somewhat expensive saddle was a peice of garbage, made in India saddle.
Posted via Mobile Device
 

· Registered
Joined
·
13,166 Posts
This site has good prices , the most expensive one I got a quote for was like $750 I believe

Handcrafted Saddles by Dakota - Page 1

I can post the prices I got from them tomorrow but they do all kinds of customizing for you. I'm also looking into a dakota!
A few years ago I got a saddle from them. I'm only ~an hour away from their shop so I was able to go and see them. Good deal and good guy to deal with, in my experience.

I had two saddles done by SouthernTrails Western Saddles, Trail Saddles, Barrel Saddle, Ranch Saddle who is a member here. If you call Kevin, he will walk you through any concerns and I understand he deals with Dakota as well. I'm still riding the last one I got from him and I've put in hundreds of hours in it over the past year.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,847 Posts
Discussion Starter · #9 ·
I actually got a Dakota barrel racer from my parents for Christmas but still have yet to ride in it!
Posted via Mobile Device
 

· Registered
Joined
·
17,286 Posts
I read on the trail saddle which states Steele equi fit fiberglass covered flex tree. Fiberglass isn't flexible. The roper tree offers a 5 year warranty. Does that warranty expire the minute the saddle leaves the retailer? My Tex Tan offered a 5 year guarantee - big difference. If considering a Dakota, be sure to read the fine print if there's a warranty. I don't know of a saddlemaker in North America who can make a custom saddle for $750 unless he opts to work for less than min. wage.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
14,220 Posts
I read on the trail saddle which states Steele equi fit fiberglass covered flex tree. Fiberglass isn't flexible. The roper tree offers a 5 year warranty. Does that warranty expire the minute the saddle leaves the retailer? My Tex Tan offered a 5 year guarantee - big difference. If considering a Dakota, be sure to read the fine print if there's a warranty. I don't know of a saddlemaker in North America who can make a custom saddle for $750 unless he opts to work for less than min. wage.
This link discusses the Steele equifit flex tree:

Steele Saddle Tree LLC - EQUI-FIT FLEXIBLE (EFF)

That should answer your 'isn't flexible' comment.

Why do you ask if a 5 year warranty expires the moment the saddle leaves the retailer? Unless it is a fly-by-night company - and neither Steele nor Dakota are those - then the warranty starts when the saddle is purchased for use. 5 years is fairly common in western saddles.

"Circle Y saddles have a ten year tree warranty, a one year parts warranty, and a one year silver warranty. Saddles have a warranty registration card attached which contain a complete explanation of the warranties. All warranties apply to the original purchaser. Saddles manufactured before January 1, 2004 have a five-year tree warranty."

Circle Y Saddles - Western Saddles, Trail Riding Saddles, Barrel Sadles, Roping Saddles

"All our leather Tex Tan saddles have a five year warranty on the tree"

Tex Tan Need for Speed Barrel Saddle

I have no clue why someone would think TexTan has a superior warranty.

Dakota doesn't offer custom saddles. They offer semi-custom. That means standardized parts, with some interchangeability as the saddle is being made. I don't know what they pay, but they are not pretending they offer a true custom made saddle.

BTW - here is a list of folks using Steele trees:

Steele Saddle Tree LLC - Vendor Directory
 

· Registered
Joined
·
566 Posts
Just my opinion the Dakotas are probably made better than the Circle Y nowadays. Circle Y since it has become super popular is mass produced and tends to have defects that were not previously seen. Small saddle makers still treat their saddle making as a skill. I have had a couple different Dakotas. One I wish I still had.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
I know this is an old thread but I am trying to get the word out about the Dakota saddles. I bought a new Dakota roping saddle in 2004. I didn't realize how badly the saddle was fitting my QH. His back got so bad & his walk became so rough & he stumbled frequintely. I sold him because of this. I then started riding my young horse but could never get her to properly canter. I could spur spank or whatever & she would rather take that than canter. Otherwise she rode good except she wanted to shortstep alot. So then... I started riding another young horse & since she was grey she very quickly got two white spots on her withers. I really liked my saddle so I was trying to use different padding to correct this. I specifically ordered full QH bars on this saddle. Out of the blue she started bucking after riding alot. Now she has a knot on her left wither. I immediately traded my Dakota for an HR ranch cutter & to my surprise my horse with canter & the other quit bucking. Afriend of mine who purchased the same kind of saddle after I did is having the same problem on the left side of his horse. I am so upset about selling Elvis because I am sure I was responsible for the condition he was in. This problem almost caused me to be severly injured. I hope this can be helpful to someone out there. Spend the extra money on the HR saddles. I am glad I did. My horses are much happier besides it is so much more comfortable.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
910 Posts
I own a Dakita reining saddle. Never had a problem. In the shop getting new blevins buckles now. It fits all my guys just fine.
Posted via Mobile Device
 

· Registered
Joined
·
2,847 Posts
Discussion Starter · #16 ·
So because it took you going through THREE horses to figure out your saddle is a bad fit your blaming th saddle company? You do realize every saddle fits different just like a shirt or a pair of pants fit each person differently.


Please don't be ignorant and blame the saddle maker. I've never had an issue with mine and I love mine. Every saddle fits every horse differently.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
  • Like
Reactions: HunterEq95

· Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
Dakota Saddles

Was happy with them have a Custom tooled and color reiner that ran about 850.00 new 5-6 years ago. Now also a nearly new Custom tooled special color Arab tree hybrid trail saddle that was close to a 1,000.00. Not even two years old and seat in that is just crap padding went flat under seat bones, :evil:wear in the center of the leather and a object of some kind nearly breaking through the very thin grade grain out leather.

They are not being very nice about repairing it either or even admitting to something of a QA problem When a seat has huge seat bone divots and a nail head poking up through the seat maybe a problem here with Them. I feel ok I'll pay shipping one way not happy with the rest of what they think I should pay. This saddle looks new barely has any miles on it. Thehorsesaddleshop.com was the dealer on this and did a good job getting it built for me but, not a good advocate job now the this is an issue. So far not happy will update this if they reach out and get back to me. e-mails and phone calls just result in them wanting me to pay shipping two ways and at "cost" repair.
 

Attachments

· Registered
Joined
·
3 Posts
After the spanking I got on what I wrote upearlier I had no other reply. My saddle had the very same seat but it didn't become defective like yours. I am sad it took me 3 horses to realize I had a problem. Everything was so gradual with the 1st horse & then the fact the 2nd one would not canter. Just never put it together until the 3rd horse just threw a fit. I guess stupid me but I have a HR Ranch cutter now & it is awesome. But it is very heavy. Sits like a rocking chair. Thank you for the reply I thought I was the only person unhappy with the Dakota.
 
1 - 20 of 27 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top