The Horse Forum banner

Status
Not open for further replies.
1 - 13 of 13 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
30 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Alright it is me again :). I am thinking about switching to Seminole Pro-Plus 12 sweet. I was curious to if anyone else has used it before? Do you know how much it is and does it do the job?
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,962 Posts
I don't like straight sweet feed at ALL...I use Nutrena Safe Choice which is a dry pellet and mix in Purina Omolene 200 that is an all grain feed (kinda like a sweet feed but ALOT btter) for my barrel horse..my other horse is 21 and he gets Nutrena Life Design Senior..I just don't think sweet feeds cut it..I wouldn't recommend it to anyone..and you definitly get what you pay for..Cheap prices mean cheap feed..Just my opinion..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
182 Posts
I stay away from all sweet feeds. Far too much sugar. I prefer a dry pellet.
+1.

I don't feed any grains, period. My gelding is a very easy keeper though; all he gets, aside from hay, is just enough soaked alfalfa pellets to mix his vit/min supplement and rice bran in.

Can you tell us a bit more about your horse - age, work load, any health problems, easy/hard keeper, does he need to gain weight, lose, maintain, etc.? What is he getting right now (in weight please)? Type of hay/how much?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,962 Posts
ugh no..I looked it up and I wouldn't feed that ever..
<<Amazing feed..has ALOT better stuff in it than the seminole..

< great stuff for a working horse..


Purina even has this thing going now called The Sixty Day Challenge..you should try that..it's like you feed their feed for 60 days and if you don't see a difference in your horse they will buy the feed..

Purina Mills - Purina Difference<BR>Rewards
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
57 Posts
See I think SafeChoice is too high in sugar/starch too. It's 20% sugar and starch where most sweet feed is 30-40%. I also have one choke prone horse so I can't feed pellets.

So I feed Triple Crown Senior. It's 11% sugar/starch, 17% fiber, 10% fat and 14% protein. It has too many calories for my adults so I cut it with TC's 30% supplement. They get what they need without too much sugar.

Having said all this, what you're "supposed" to do per Dr. Kellon the equine vet specializing in nutrition is have your hay tested and supplement to balance your hay and that's it. My hay source isn't consistent and well.... I'm lazy :)

ETA: My horses aren't in even moderate work though I do have a couple young ones. I have no idea really how to feed a horse that's worked hard.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,962 Posts
See I think SafeChoice is too high in sugar/starch too. It's 20% sugar and starch where most sweet feed is 30-40%. I also have one choke prone horse so I can't feed pellets.

So I feed Triple Crown Senior. It's 11% sugar/starch, 17% fiber, 10% fat and 14% protein. It has too many calories for my adults so I cut it with TC's 30% supplement. They get what they need without too much sugar.

Having said all this, what you're "supposed" to do per Dr. Kellon the equine vet specializing in nutrition is have your hay tested and supplement to balance your hay and that's it. My hay source isn't consistent and well.... I'm lazy :)

ETA: My horses aren't in even moderate work though I do have a couple young ones. I have no idea really how to feed a horse that's worked hard.
Yeah, I see exactly what you're saying..My mare is worked/ridden about 5 or 6 days a week and my gelding is about 3 or so ( I get lazy with him)..but I like it alot because I do have performance horses and it works really well for them..and I didn't say anything about the hay in my last post but I completely agree with you..I don't think your feed is going to do any good if you don't have nice hay..

my horses are also free choice supplements in the pasture with them.forgot that too..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
923 Posts
I agree about the sweet feed I feed 11:8 11% protein with 8% fat. Its a dry pellet. It still has sugar but very little. Along with that I feed MSM joint supplement during the winter months and a vitamin. And of course minerals.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,825 Posts
seven7max- Seminole offers way better feeds than that one. Tell us a little about your horse and we can help you pick the right Seminole feed for you if you wish to stick with that brand. I personally use Wellness Compete Safe.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
30 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
seven7max- Seminole offers way better feeds than that one. Tell us a little about your horse and we can help you pick the right Seminole feed for you if you wish to stick with that brand. I personally use Wellness Compete Safe.

I appreciate all the input. :)

I guess I need to ad to my original post. I am in college, have a truck(expensive on gas), two horses(vet bills expensive...), hay cost,... Need I go on. That is one of the only reasons I wanted to find something a little cheaper. I feed safechoice to both of my horse ad give them wach a small amount of sweet feed just for a littlw treat(sugar...). My Walker(Seven) has bad allergies. I was thinking of Nutrena Legacy Pellets. I read somewhere that it was a good choice for allergy prone horses. Percheron Paint(Max) cross is somewhat of an easy keeper. They get pasture at night, stall during the day with hay. I am trying to think of everything, sorry if I leave something out.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,138 Posts
I don't like straight sweet feed at ALL...I use Nutrena Safe Choice which is a dry pellet and mix in Purina Omolene 200 that is an all grain feed (kinda like a sweet feed but ALOT btter) for my barrel horse..my other horse is 21 and he gets Nutrena Life Design Senior..I just don't think sweet feeds cut it..I wouldn't recommend it to anyone..and you definitly get what you pay for..Cheap prices mean cheap feed..Just my opinion..
SafeChoice has just as much sugar in the form of starch as sweet feed. You're not really helping your horse's diet much with that mix, besides throwing the nutritent balance out of whack.

Any feed, pelleted, textured (Omelene is textured), or whole grains that has corn or corn and molasses in it is high in sugars/starches and not that great for your horse.

Compare sweet feed to cookies. They have some nutrient value, but mostly sugar.

Compare high starch pelleted or textured feeds to cereal or power bars. They have more nutrition and even fiber/protein, but they still have LOADS of sugar and are not that healthy eaten on a regular basis.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,138 Posts
If you feed grass hay/pasture, I would feed Seminole's Equalizer, which is a ration balancer. You only feed 1-2 lbs a day per horse.
Seminole Equalizer - Ration Balancer for horses

For the horses that need added calories, add to their feed alfalfa pellets or shredded beet pulp, 2-4 lbs a day, and a fat source like flax meal or other flax-based fat supplement product. I really like Standlee Alfalfa or Alfalfa/Timothy hay pellets. My tractor supply carries them in 40 lbs bags for $7.99/10.99 respectively. They're very affordable to feed. And, if you buy 20 bags of feed at a time, you get a 5% discount. You can mix and match different feeds, even dog/cat food ;-).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
30 Posts
Discussion Starter #13
If you feed grass hay/pasture, I would feed Seminole's Equalizer, which is a ration balancer. You only feed 1-2 lbs a day per horse.
Seminole Equalizer - Ration Balancer for horses

For the horses that need added calories, add to their feed alfalfa pellets or shredded beet pulp, 2-4 lbs a day, and a fat source like flax meal or other flax-based fat supplement product. I really like Standlee Alfalfa or Alfalfa/Timothy hay pellets. My tractor supply carries them in 40 lbs bags for $7.99/10.99 respectively. They're very affordable to feed. And, if you buy 20 bags of feed at a time, you get a 5% discount. You can mix and match different feeds, even dog/cat food ;-).
Alrighty. This sounds like a good idea. luvs2ride1979 Thanks for the help.
I will also look at other post to and take them into consideration.
 
1 - 13 of 13 Posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top