The two year old is not Specacular Spirit. The ad says the 2 year old is not registered but has the paperwork ready to register him(which I highly encourage). His sire is Spectacular Spirit and he is out of Coral Cove. The picture on his ad, I am fairly certain, is Spectacular Spirit, and they do not have a picture of him.
Spectacular Spirit, according to the ASHA records is a bay stallion, born in 2003, and has one registered foal, a bay 2009 filly, which is that $10,000 baby. Never been shown, and still with the person who bred him.
Miss Fizz is a nice old gal. She is a 1987 model, and has six foals to date. She has had six owners in her life, and has been with her current owner since 2003. She has never been shown, and only two of her foals have been shown. Likely she was never broke to ride.
If only out of those two, I would suggest getting the two year old, and get him registered(so that he is on the books and his life recorded). This would require you to join the Saddlebred Association, pay the registration fees, DNA him, choose a name... etc. I only say him over the mare, because you would just be getting the mare to retire. However, the gelding was injured as a baby, and might not be sound. His dam is sure pretty. They have her on there for $1000. She's a nice mare.
If I were to suggest a horse from that seller, I would go with the 21 year old trail horse, to get you started with saddlebreds. He is absolutely ADORABLE! And he still has some good years left in him. He has never been shown, but he looks like a real good horse.
Or, if you are looking for a Saddlebred to start, I would look at the Whitewater Creek horse. He is typey, refined, and very talented. He is a cute horse, very expressive, and young. Perfect age to start, and you could really get somewhere with him. I don't even like Pintos, but he is a nice one. He will be different from any other horse you have had, because, just by his pictures, he has a motor, and will like to show off. He is probably very snorty, showy and cocky. I like him.
What are you looking for in a horse?