Would you consider a Percheron X a good dressage horse? why or why not?
- Status
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
Joined
·
5,349 Posts
Joined
·
1,032 Posts
It would depend on the horse and its build. All horses of one breed are not built the same. Look for a perch with a more sloping shoulder versus an upright shoulder, and one that can track his back legs well under him. My perch is a level 2 trained horse, but I don't ride dressage myself, I'm more of a pleasure rider. Maybe someday!
Joined
·
780 Posts
Forrest Hill Farm breeds Percheron/Thoroughbred horses and they are rather impressive horses. :wink:
Forrest Hill Farm dressage breeders history
Forrest Hill Farm dressage breeders history
Joined
·
12,825 Posts
This.
Not something you can make a blanket statement on.
Draft horses (generalization) are designed to pull with their strong front ends. Their back ends are not designed to push underneath like you want in a dressage horse.
It also depends on what level of dressage you are aiming to do. Any horse can do lower levels.
Joined
·
5,061 Posts
I have almost bought a couple of Perch crosses, because their movement was very good for dressage; unfortunately there had been other people there before, me, and they purchased the horses...
I do think it's going to come down with how the horse has been bred though, and not so much about the 'cross'...the ones I was after were both Paint crosses. But their parents both complimented each other, so the resulting babies had nice build, and nice movement.
I do think it's going to come down with how the horse has been bred though, and not so much about the 'cross'...the ones I was after were both Paint crosses. But their parents both complimented each other, so the resulting babies had nice build, and nice movement.
Joined
·
8,466 Posts
It would depend on the horse. I've seen ShireXTB crosses and PercheronXTrakhener Dressage before.
Joined
·
3,199 Posts
There was a HUGE debate on this just a little bit ago. It all depends on the build and breeding of the horse. Some crosses come out really good and some (even the same cross) come out not so good. Either way any horse can do dressage, it also depends on how competitive you really want to be.
Joined
·
1,527 Posts
My boss has one, she does level three? Whenever I watch her ride it's beautiful, however, I can hear the horse from a mile away. And you can tell she has to work hard.
To sort of recap the previous thread on the subject:
A cross resists generalizations because a cross doesn't run true to type - you can have a Perch/TB cross that comes out looking almost entirely like the Perch parent, entirely like the TB parent, or a combination of the worst traits of both. Or you can have a happy result and get a Perch/TB cross that has the warmblood type conformation that's ideal for dressage, but that's statistically less common. (In the previous thread, a poster get very upset at the criticism of draft crosses as sport horses and post photos of some gorgeous 50% draft crosses that looked and performed like warmbloods. Gorgeous, but not typical.)
So you'd be better off analyzing the confo of the individual horse for suitability for dressage rather than trying to make a generalization about the cross.
Also, you need to consider exactly what you want the horse to do - almost any sound horse can do training and first level, however, if you want to show and be competitive, it's best to have a horse that looks the part and has the movement. If you have aspirations above second level, you must evaluate the horse for its ability to collect.
A cross resists generalizations because a cross doesn't run true to type - you can have a Perch/TB cross that comes out looking almost entirely like the Perch parent, entirely like the TB parent, or a combination of the worst traits of both. Or you can have a happy result and get a Perch/TB cross that has the warmblood type conformation that's ideal for dressage, but that's statistically less common. (In the previous thread, a poster get very upset at the criticism of draft crosses as sport horses and post photos of some gorgeous 50% draft crosses that looked and performed like warmbloods. Gorgeous, but not typical.)
So you'd be better off analyzing the confo of the individual horse for suitability for dressage rather than trying to make a generalization about the cross.
Also, you need to consider exactly what you want the horse to do - almost any sound horse can do training and first level, however, if you want to show and be competitive, it's best to have a horse that looks the part and has the movement. If you have aspirations above second level, you must evaluate the horse for its ability to collect.
Joined
·
5,184 Posts
In general, horses with draft blood do not have correct movement for dressage. Draft horses do not have a moment of suspension in their gait, which is crucial to dressage.
As previously mentioned, they are also built to pull, not carry.
I would not recommend a draft cross as a dressage prospect, although they can do lower levels. A very well built one might potentially make it to PSG, but I think you would be extremely hard pressed to find a draft cross that can perform a piaffe/passage correct enough to show at GP.
As previously mentioned, they are also built to pull, not carry.
I would not recommend a draft cross as a dressage prospect, although they can do lower levels. A very well built one might potentially make it to PSG, but I think you would be extremely hard pressed to find a draft cross that can perform a piaffe/passage correct enough to show at GP.
Joined
·
147 Posts
A friend of mine was schooling and competing one who was doing really well, and had huge stunning movement but he was built like a tank!
Joined
·
3,968 Posts
No, no, no. Crossing a draft with a TB does not a warmblood make. Not even "basically" a warmblood. It makes a draft cross. A mutt. Generally mutts with good personalities, but mutts all the same. Like my horses. They are NOT Warmbloods!
Joined
·
5,892 Posts
When people call to see what we have in the rescue in the way of horses, we always mention rosie...a perch cross. Immediatly the response is "What level dressage does she do? Can she jump? How high?" Since she is the only perch cross that I've ever ridden, I can assure you that she is not the dancy prancy dressage type. Jumping is totally out of the question. Im sure there are some great perch crosses out there but not all are created equal.
Attachments
Joined
·
3,968 Posts
Haha lok at her NECK! Aww, she's darling....but yeah definitely not dressage/jumper material!
Joined
·
3,077 Posts
The horse (mutt as you out it
) would actually be warmblooded, even if it is not a warmblood we all know and love. crossing drafts with hot bloods was how we got the foundation warmbloods 100s of years ago. i got this info from: 'The Horse: A Complete Guide' not my info before you start pointing fingers! although it makes perfect sense to me.I googled 'percheron dressage' and some good info came up and some really nice looking pictures at really high levels but they were all crosses
Joined
·
16,508 Posts
Why do so many people think this? Crossing a cold blood with a hot blood does not make a warmblood! All it does is make a CROSS, who may or may not get the traits to make it a dressage prospect!
Speedy, that's like saying breeding an Arabian stallion with an English heavy hunter mare will get a TB. Not so.
Warmbloods are a breed, like TBs, because they bred true to type. Breeding a draft with a TB does NOT make a warmblood, regardless of what you may have read in a book somewhere.
Joined
·
16,508 Posts
That's also like saying breeding a Mastiff and an Irish Greyhound will produce Great Dane puppies.
Those two breeds may have been the originators of the Dane breed, but Danes are now a breed unto themselves, and an outcross to either of those breeds would mean the puppies were MUTTS.
Those two breeds may have been the originators of the Dane breed, but Danes are now a breed unto themselves, and an outcross to either of those breeds would mean the puppies were MUTTS.
1 - 20 of 22 Posts
- Status
Join the discussion
