What Thouroughbred do you think the greatest of all time was and why? What discipline were/are they used for?
I have a APHA with both Native and Northern Dancer.........This is Golden Dancer.....lol!!! aka Denny........unfortunately he has a moderate case of PSSM and is unrideabeMine is native dancer and northern dancer both winning twice in Kentucky derby very famous look em up and my tb is grandaughter of northern dancer and great granddaughter of native dancer on her dam and sires side
Posted via Mobile Device
bred in NZ hehe :Pphar lap came to australia when he was young
It's kind of ironic how both horses were 16.3 hh, both nicknamed Big Red & both raced 21 times!Secretariat. No doubt. Followed very closely by Man O'War.
Because he is in most of the famous racehorses lineages, is why he is also very famous. Many people went to his funeral(or was it his retirement?) Also they bred Secretariat to almost anything. And if it weren't for Man O' War Secretariat wouldn't be here.I have not seen the movie, and I still plan to.any horse people I know saw the movie and loved it.Man O'War seems to be the favorite of most. Yes, he was the Greatest horse in the first 1/2 of the 20th Century, but what about --- drumroll here ---- SECRETARIAT.
It is Secretariat who still olds the 1 1/2 mile World Record at 2:24, running each furlong at 12 seconds or less. No horse has come within 2 seconds of Secretariat's Belmont mark, and that Secretariat movie did a real harm(in my opinion) to people who have never seen the video of the real 1973 Belmont Stakes. Please watch it on Youtube.
This is my first post here, and my id is: Lovebigred, because SECRETARIAT, also known as Big Red, was the horse I fell in love with at age 10. But no horse since Secretariat has ever come close to his time record, and no one ever will.
I don't think I was intentionally saying he wasn't a great racehorse, because he was. I was just stating what others have told me and what I have read about him. Don't think I said it was fact either. And I found your post rather offensive. Also he was bred with pretty much anything, I never said he was overbred. I also never stated that none of his offspring was horrible and that he failed as a sire. I know very well he was a great producer of champions. I am a fan as well.1st: Man O'War's funeral was on the radio and many people went to his funeral, yes, that is true.
I can appreciate your love for Man O'War.
2nd: They DID NOT breed Secretariat to "almost anything" as you think. Secretariat was bred to 40 mares a year at most, and he was in no way overbred. SECRETARIAT will live on in the Thoroughbred breed through his daughters, who were exceptional producers, especially of stallions. Storm Cat, the most successful Thoroughbred stallion in the past 20 years was out of Secretariat's daughter, Terlingua. Gone West, another very successful stallion was out of Secrettame. And, perhaps the stallion who is the savior of the Bold Ruler male line, A.P. INDY, was born from Weekend Surprise, another daughter of Secretariat.
3rd: How can you say that if it was not for Man O'War, Secretariat wouldn't be here? I am sorry, but that does not make sense. Secretariat has no Man O'War blood or breeding anywhere in his pedigree. In fact, Secretariat was produced almost exclusively from stallions imported to the USA after the year 1900. Only one of his lines, that of his sire, Bold Ruler, who's dam was Miss Disco, by Discovery, who was by Display, by Fair Play, has any American blood at all.
This is my first post on here, and I didn't want to start an arguement, but rightly so, I do have to put to rest any misconceptions of fact.
If anything, Secretariat will live on in more then just the Thoroughbred breed. There were 2 mares bred to Secretariat as test mares to see if he could get a mare in foal. Of those 2 mares, one was an Appaloosa, and that resulting foal - First Secretary, is in the Appaloosa Racing Hall of Fame. The 2nd foal was born from a Begium mare, and was named Statesman. Here's an article on Statesman: Statesman - gelding by Secretariat
Back to the movie. The Belmont Stakes scenes were filmed at Keeneland racetrack in Lexington. The way the Belmont was filmed it is(in my opinion) close to impossible to understand what Secretariat really did in that Belmont Stakes of 1973. Anyone who watches the race in the movie could not fully understand what happened by just watching the movie itself. That is my opinion.
MUDPAINT:I personally love Secretariat. Though Man O War or Bold Ruler would come in close second for the racing TBs.
But if we're talking about all time favorite Tbs... I'll have to throw in Gem Twist. Having actually seen him compete with Laura Chapot, he's my favorite.
I guess my list would look like:
Gem Twist
Secretariat
Man O War
Ruffian
Unbridled Song--actually saw him at the wood memorial and a leading sire. Plus he's drop dead gorgeous!
Unbridled -- one of the first Kentucky Derbies I've seen in person
Cigar
There's an Eventer that I can't think of the name of... I know he was smallish and from the 90s.